I know YOU know that people are often judged based on their choice of news outlets. “I don’t believe the liberal media” or “he heard that on Fox News”.
Did you know that this isn't new? Before the US Civil War, there were separate mailed newspapers that went to people with different political views. This whole Fox News vs. MSNBC thing isn’t new. There were entire newspapers devoted to journalistic obliteration of Andrew Jackson and entire newspapers devoted to supporting him. Often the separate newspapers were actually funded entirely and openly by political parties!
There are always multiple views on any issue, particularly on political and social “hot topics”.. There are always different ways to look at an issue or an event.
Just ask four different kids about the most recent campus fight and you will get four different stories. Add in the AP or nearby teacher or hall monitor and you have another set of stories.
Then, wait a week and ask about that fight again. Chances are, with time and perspective, that you will have some slight variations on that fight.
Then, ask someone’s mom. Or a student from another school. And you will get yet another side to the story.
Finding the middle ground between multiple sides of the story is what CORROBORATION is all about.
Corroboration is about establishing what is most probable by comparing the documents together. It recognizes disparities between accounts.
How can I teach my kids to look at corroboration between documents and accounts?
Here are some good prompts/questions to use to help kids dig into the corroboration...- What do other documents say?
- Do the documents agree? If not, why?
- What are other possible documents?
- What documents are most reliable?
- The author agrees/disagrees with . . .
- These documents all agree/ disagree about . . .
- Another document to consider might be . . .
This is, again, a Civic Literacy skill. It’s a reading skill. It’s what Common Core asks for. It’s what the LAFS ask for. It’s what the FSA asks kids to demonstrate. It’s what we want our voters to do. IT’s what we want ALL citizens to do -- not just the “advanced” kids or the “magnet kids” or the college-bound.
We want ALL kids to understand and master the skill of corroboration!
How can we continue to give kids intentional practice corroborating? As always, I love to hear from you! Email me at newmantr@pcsb.org
-Tracy
